jacob black

I like him with bella but i like edward with bella

yeah she fits both of them

but she fits with Edward more. She's never told Jake that she couldn't live without him. and she didn't go off and spiral into depression when he like left her.

She's told Edward that she can't live without him. And she almost died because he left her. True love right there people!

yeah but its not like she can leave jacob because she did say that she loved jacob so she sort of cant live without both

well, she's gunna have to be able to leave Jacob...he kinda left. And she did live without him for like her whole life...and she had met him before. She hadn't ever met Edward until that year in Forks High....

yeah edward kinda left to
she wouldnt want both of them
out of her life

i wouldn't want both of them out of my life either though. Jake i could deal with, but Edward? nuh uh! lol

yeah thats true it would be to much to handle

exactly. lol

lol yeah now i really understand why bella felt like she was dying when he left

? how so?

because all the girls would feel like that it would be very sad

yeah...lol. i know that i did when he left her in the book. lol

yeah me too and i kinda got mad to because how can he leave her?!

i know right?! lol i would never leave you Edward....*sigh*

lol none of the girls would leave him

yeah, but considering that he is like hot, who can blaim us for not wanting to leave him?? lol

yeah lol

But for real, I think I would end up dying if he left again.

I was in Band Class when I read that part the first time. I was trying soo hard not to cry, but then the teacher took the book.... and threw it....on the ground. I was so mad! lol Then I read it again and cried for a long time. lol

yeah I read New Moon in a day not because it was my favorite book but because I just wanted to get to the part where Edward returned. As for Jacob I don't like him and I never will for many reasons but the main one is that he ripped a new hole in her heart that she will have forever. Back in New Moon Edward did the same thing which is why she wouldn't date Jacob she said he didn't deserve "damaged goods" well Edward repaired his hole but Jacob planted a new one by forcing Bella to realize she loves him and now Edward is the one with the "damaged goods" and no Edward doesn't mind but I do he deserves better and Because of Jake he will always have doubt.

Emma, this is how I think of Jacob.

He is like a little brother to Bella in many ways. Well, maybe sick step brother who's loved her for a long time *starts to think*.....anyways. He can't help what he feels for her. I don't think that Bella--well, i know that bella isn't the right person for him, but he still deserves someone to have and to hold. in sickness and in health.

okay, is it just me or do i sound like i'm marrying Jacob to an imaginary PERSON? lol

No, if he's going to marry anybody, it's gunna be Tiff. Don't ask why, but she really likes him....? *shrug* she's just wierd like that. but i still love her.

that happened 2 one of my friends

Yeah its true that jacob would get damaged goods but I don't think that edward would get damaged goods because even if she did go with edward she would try to be friends with jake even if she does become a vampire jake would try to he said it himself

Yeah I agree that Jacob needs someone good to but he will never find her unless he just gives up on Bella already! And well Jacob says one thing but does another all the time. Personally I just want him to imprint and then I won't have a problem with him and all will be good.

I'm with Bella, I love him, I'm just not in love with him.

yeah he is more like a brother to her